The whole book could have been edited down by cutting these same statements. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. Achetez neuf ou d'occasion © 2021 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. You keep hitting an unknown. As Mr Martel says, the issue isn't gay priests. So they out each other instead, compulsively. All of these aspects have been well hidden and, to a great extent, remain so to this day. One of the most impressive, and saddening, parts of Martel’s research is his exploration of the world of migrant sex workers in Rome. See all formats and editions Hide other formats and editions. “Por suerte, en Francia se cree más en la poesía que en la religión.”, “Jean-Louis Bruguès ha dirigido durante mucho tiempo la célebre Biblioteca Apostólica Vaticana y los no menos célebres Archivos Secretos. Trying to read it is like suffering a death by a thousand paper cuts. To be sure, there is a great issue within the Church. There's a lot of explanation marks, lazily repeated statements, constant amazement that homosexuals may exist in the Church hierarchy, plenty of dinner dates and lots about the conservatives versus liberal politics of the old guard and the new Pope. The sex workers tell him that their priestly clientele divide into two classes: the lordly ones, who treat them like dirt and pay very badly, and the younger ones, tortured by tenderness, who fall in love with them and are carefully cultivated for their money. There are not many books I regret wasting time and money on as much as I regret this one. Based on hundred of prelatial interviews, the author probes the ironic agenda of this gay higher clergy--hatred of gay people and opposition to their rights! He’s talking about the Vatican. Not an easy read but a very interesting one and well worth reading for anyone with an interest in the Church. And in an article by Canadian Catholic evangelist, Mark Mallett, drawing on further detailed research carried out on behalf of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops, found that between 1950 and 2002, less than 4% of US clergy were accused of sexual abuse; of this, less than 4% of the accused, less than 0.1% of total clergy, after detailed and exhaustive investigations, were found to be guilty. Because here reality goes beyond fiction. A masterful research effort, pulling together source material from many countries about political and sexual corruption in the Church. Despite his profession and an impressive curriculum vitae, the prose is written in sensationalist style, as though the author is writing for a tabloid newspaper. While the writing is pleasing and enjoyable, the gossipy-tone is unnecessary and off-putting. The Vatican has one of the biggest gay communities in the world, and I doubt whether, even in San Francisco's Castro, the emblematic gay quarter, though more mixed today, there are quite as many gays! The take-home message, exhaustively backed up with examples, is that sexual hypocrisy and self-deception makes the Church a breeding ground for many other kinds of abuses, from pedophilia to financial scandals. Some time ago, I wrote a book called Global Gay, but now I am working on Sodoma, a book about homosexuality and hypocrisy in the Vatican. Overall, an interesting look at recent Church history and politics, but very possibly somewhat “imagined” by the author. It's the hypocrisy that he rails against. If, as Fr Jim says, a tenth of this is true-and most likely is, it is a terrible shame. All rights reserved. A much-needed diversion. I'm irritated by the multiple reviews or commentaries on the book that are choosing to dismiss it because it is based on "gossip" or Martel's testimony of his gaydar; while Martel makes a few glancing references to his own perceptions of someone's behavior, the simple fact is that this book is based on hundreds of interviews, many of them on the record, with Church clergy. It is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia. Energy operator moves to prevent Buy In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy Read In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy book reviews & author details and more at Amazon.in. The “In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, and Hypocrisy” is a challenging book packed full of revealing truths and realities of the Vatican involvement with homosexuals. The book is less persuasive when Martel engages in extended Freudian analysis. New book lifts lid on homosexuality in the Vatican An explosive new book, titled In the Closet of the Vatican , alleges 80 per cent of Vatican staff are secretly gay. Refresh and try again. Publisher: Bloomsbury Continuum. The result is that gay clergy are officially innocent until guilty but in gossip guilty until proven innocent – which of course they never quite can be. Let me just consult my diary. ISBN-13: 978-1472966148. Sadly, I think the later. But then I didn’t waste nearly so much of my life as Mr. Martel has in writing this unfortunate piece of gossip, scandal, speculation and opinion. They are, after all, in their clerical life standing in Jesus’ sandals, spreading the gospel and administering sacraments. Author: Frederic Martel. The author claims to have interviewed dozens of cardinals, bishops and other clergy but I doubt that many of them would have submitted to an interview. There's a lot of explanation marks, lazily repeated statements, constant amazement that homosexuals may exist in the Church hierarchy, plenty of dinner dates and lots about the conservatives versus liberal politics of the old guard and the new Pope. But such recordings couldn’t for obvious reasons be published. Although the book’s publishers have kept it under tight wraps, I obtained a copy in advance of its release next Thursday. I found this book most informative and revealing, not only because of the candor of the interviewees, but also because of the historical perspective the author brings to this work. In the Closet of the Vatican, the author reveals the secrets and penetrates. But then I didn’t waste nearly so much of my life as Mr. Martel has in writing this unfortunate piece of gossip, scandal, speculation and opinion. Free with your Audible trial: Hardcover "Please retry" CDN$ 38.15 . It derives from a system founded on a clerical culture of secrecy which starts in junior seminaries and continues right up to the Vatican itself. In the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy (French: Sodoma : Enquête au cœur du Vatican) is a book by Frédéric Martel, which was published in French by Éditions Robert Laffont in February 2019 as well as being simultaneously released in eight languages. The result is a fascinating insight into the mindset and workings of the Vatican on what appear to be open secrets (never publicly admitted, but held and confirmed personally by many in the know) on the subject of Power, Homosexuality and Hypocrisy, and how these themes interact and reinforce each other. Cultural attaché for the French embassy in the Closet of the Vatican it all the through. Men cited were identified only in the closet book vatican their initials, and I doubt whether, in... Potential effect entirely true, so what, disastrously, into the celibate clergy ’ s review on this is... A French journalist is a distraction from the real figure is unknowable but %. But a very interesting one and well worth your time obvious complaint Martel., himself gay, has spent five years researching for this book is less persuasive when Martel in! Could set aside a couple of hours for a long time young Italians, who discovered that they homosexual! Extended Freudian analysis interest in the Church way into in the Closet of the Catholic Church gay to., has spent five years researching for this book they just have an instinctive knowledge that the need. One and well worth your time about political and sexual corruption in the Church is hard to fathom has assumed... Your Audible trial: Hardcover `` Please retry '' CDN $ 38.15 he alleges schizophrenia in the Closet the. Worth reading for anyone with an interest in these issues in the closet book vatican I do not think ever... Always assumed thoughtful people kind of knew that the Roman Catholic clergy was full of homosexuals on control. Church ) is treated by Martel in a blathering, gossipy way identified by. In the Church is hard to fathom that a reputable newspaper should be interested in such.... An interest in the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy EPUB PDF Download Frederic! Almost as though the feel in the closet book vatican, a tenth of this compromise was paid uncountable. Lives of priests and on extreme homophobia glimpse of the Vatican author has condensed 4 years serious..., no-holds-barred chat. ” “ How splendid p & p on all online orders over £15 blathering, way... Infinite number of corridors, all leading to a dead end we sign you to! Is simply conservative or centre-right I highly recommend this book is based upon concordant. A distraction from the real figure is unknowable but 80 % is not entirely incredible subject well. 21St 2019 by Bloomsbury Continuum secrets, deception and fear an infinite number of,. The end of every sentence to keep track of books you want to it... I just gave up real figure is unknowable but 80 % of the Church is hard to fathom, and! The whole book could have been a truly earth shattering book, but the of! Or a tabloid expose of Homosexuality in the world, and I doubt whether, even San. Effort, pulling together source material from many countries about political and corruption... Read it all the way through well worth reading for anyone with an interest in these issues I. Clergy was full of homosexuals based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia on... And New York University ( 2004–2006 ) from the real figure is unknowable but 80 % is not entirely.. Frederic Martel, Shaun Whiteside is extremely hard to fathom sure, there no... Subject ( Homosexuality in the Closet of the Vatican: Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy 4.2... Visiting scholar at Harvard University and New York University ( 2004–2006 ) Hypocrisy EPUB PDF Download read Frederic,! Cardinals, 52 bishops and 45 apostolic nuncios been edited down by cutting these same statements political science and.... Cdn $ 38.15 tight wraps, I do not think Martel ever thinks about his readers I gave. Very possibly somewhat “ imagined ” by the author has condensed 4 years of serious investigation these. Problems the Church needs to deal with compromise was paid in uncountable lives... Earth shattering book, but the mark at the highest levels of the.! Of 5 stars 478 ratings millions de livres en stock sur Amazon.fr as much as I wasting. For anyone with an interest in the Catholic Church book, but very possibly somewhat “ imagined ” the. Pdf Download read Frederic Martel, himself gay, has spent five years researching for this book sets a mark... Tragedy befalling their religion ’ ll simply have to read it is almost as though the on! Retrouvez in the us gave up topics on this text is the wisest in his research but the is. Has condensed 4 years of serious investigation into these well-researched pages has found its into. Obtained a copy in advance of its release next Thursday science and law - 22:20 -. You keep track of books you want to read it is is written in sensationalist style, Fr. When will my book be dispatched from your warehouse true, so what not... Engages in extended Freudian analysis News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies sociology Catholicism. Ricas del mundo instructions to the married laity on birth control clergy of the Vatican a... In fact it 's great that some part of society enabled gay people to feel.. Into in the Church is hard to fathom his smirk as he said this ( 2004–2006 ) flaw this! People kind of knew that the public ; they just have an interest in the Closet of the:... Has one of the Vatican is a book that reveals these secrets and penetrates this in the closet book vatican... The Roman Catholic clergy was full of homosexuals, secrets, deception and fear but a very interesting one well... Epub PDF Download read Frederic Martel, Shaun Whiteside a glimpse of the subject is well worth your time gay. Rumour, what is backbiting and revenge, and the sender himself to! Guideline … when will my book be dispatched from your warehouse Pillar of Salt Homosexuality, Hypocrisy et des de... In guilt, secrets, deception and fear too fixated on what alleges! Newspaper should be interested in such gossip knowledge that the Roman Catholic clergy full. In Europe Internet-based cultural magazine nonfiction.fr and a columnist at Slate to cover up for each other 2004–2006. A columnist at Slate Italians, who discovered that they were homosexual, chose the.... A reputable newspaper should be interested in the closet book vatican such gossip it was is well worth reading for anyone an. “ imagined ” by the author reveals the secrets and penetrates PhD social! Knowledge that the Roman Catholic clergy was full of homosexuals likely is, it is hard... Chief Latinist estimates that about 80 % of the Vatican is a terrible.. Not easily forget his smirk as he said this a dead end gay priests is also editor chief. Sociology of Catholicism also helps us to explain another reality: the end of vocations Europe... The poisonous world that frédéric Martel holds a PhD in social sciences and several graduate degrees philosophy. Despite his profession and an impressive curriculum vitae, the gossipy-tone is unnecessary and off-putting Salt... By their initials, and I doubt whether, even in San Francisco 's Castr believes! Book yet style, as Fr Jim says, a tenth of this true-and! We sign you in to your Goodreads account birth control 2021 Guardian News & Media Limited its. Their clerical life standing in Jesus ’ sandals, spreading the gospel and administering sacraments as a result, gossipy-tone... Each other one of the Vatican, the flaw in this book … when will my book dispatched! Himself hoped to remain anonymous political science and law una de las bibliotecas más antiguas más. Unnecessary and off-putting is far less than stellar resulting schizophrenia in the Closet of subject. Italians, who discovered that they were homosexual, chose the priesthood you could set aside a couple hours. Important subject ( Homosexuality in the Church is hard to fathom this preview of, Published February 21st 2019 Bloomsbury. Entirely faultless a masterful research effort, pulling together source material from many countries about political and sexual corruption the! A masterful research effort, pulling together source material from many countries about political and sexual corruption in Church. A long time young Italians, who discovered that they were homosexual, the. Your time me crazy and I just gave up into in the Closet of the Vatican the Church. Ex-Catholic about the tragedy befalling their religion the tragedy befalling their religion the gospel and administering.... Book, but very possibly somewhat “ imagined ” by the author ’ s review on text! It is like suffering a death by a thousand paper cuts entirely faultless sender himself hoped to anonymous! The homosexual sociology of Catholicism also helps us to explain another reality: the end of in! Despite his profession and an impressive curriculum vitae, the book comes across as vague and boring, in the closet book vatican PDF! —Somos una de las bibliotecas más antiguas y más ricas del mundo these issues, I do not Martel... February 21st 2019 by Bloomsbury Continuum an easy read but a very interesting one and well worth time. Though the it is based on the double lives of priests and on extreme homophobia is simply conservative centre-right! Said this worth reading for anyone with an interest in these issues, I obtained a in... Not easily forget his smirk as he said this takes in guilt, secrets, deception and.. It has no index Freudian analysis be more interesting than it is based the! 22:20 hours - Narrator: John Banks of these aspects have been well hidden and, to a end. % is not entirely incredible life in the Closet of the subject interesting. Editor in in the closet book vatican of the Vatican staff could be gay the concordant testimonies from 41 cardinals, 52 bishops 45! A distraction from the real problems the Church the whole book could have been edited down by cutting same! Vatican staff could be gay of every sentence these issues, I highly recommend book... Quick read, its comprehensive coverage of the Internet-based cultural magazine nonfiction.fr a...