The Thermapop display has an accuracy of ±2°F to 248°F, while a Thermapen has an accuracy of ±0.7°F (±0.4°C). You pretty much nailed the difference...the 3 seconds. But some of you are probably wandering what makes the Thermapen 3x more expensive, and is it enough difference to justify the extra cost. I just ordered a Thermo Pop yesterday. It makes the ThermaPop’s snappy readings look pokey, and my old meat thermometers…suddenly that 10-20 seconds felt like an eternity. 1. Just what I've read. They look pretty similar to me, but the Thermopen gives a reading in 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds for the Thermopop. The True Cost of a $6 Thermometer. Like most all thermometers in this list, and exactly like the Thermapen, the Thermopop has a wide temperature … Thermoworks sells another instant-read thermometer called the Thermopop, which is nearly as good as the Thermapen Mk4, but not quite. Its ±2°F(1°C) accuracy is still tight enough for candy work, and it can also be used to stir through the whole pot for a better understanding of the temperature. Classic Thermapen vs the ThermoPop. It doesn't turn on automatically when you unfold it, like the Thermapen, because it doesn't unfold. Thermopop vs Thermopen Does anyone have enough experience with both products to comment? While the Thermapen can read temperatures within 2 – 3 seconds, the Thermopop reads temperatures in around 4 seconds. You will also be subscribed to periodic emails from ThermoWorks. ThermoPop vs Thermapen Mk4 Created October 20, 2017; Author Rozanne Paxman; Category Help with Product Selection; People often ask us about the differences between the Thermapen Mk4 and ThermoPop thermometers. I have a Thermapen, not a Javelin, so I can't say from experience. Is my Thermapen defective or is it just marketing hype. To check the efficiency of your Thermopop thermometer, you can try an ice bath test at home. I don't personally know what your experience would be with LavaTools. You can probe a piece of meat and as you pull it out it updates fast enough that you can see the temperature gradient across the meat. If I'm not mistaken OXO did fairly well. The OXO one I can get for less than half the price of the Thermapen and they seem to do the same job. If you don’t want to spend more than $30 for a hand held thermometer, go buy the ThermoPop. But you won't go wrong with Thermoworks. 5. Hi guys, I did an AB comparison between the Thermapen and Thermopop and was surprised at the performance difference. You need not worry about repair as it also comes with a two-year warranty. They are obviously aimed at slightly different markets, with the Thermopop being a more budget friendly thermometer. For starters, it is a thermistor thermometer with a 3-4 second response time. The Best Compact Inexpensive Thermometer: The Javelin by Lavatools Let’s break down the main differences. shop at my store http://amazonjack.store2. It is also very well built, I have had mine for a few years already and it is still going strong. If you are your typical at home smoker, cooking a few pcs of meat, it's not worth the extra money. The cost difference is a bit much for the benefits but I also have MCS so I could'nt help myself. 4. Each thermometer has its own certificate of calibration. Standard dial probe thermometers are famously inexpensive, generally $6 or less. ThermoPop Thermometer Thermapen Grill Beast BBQ Grilling Cooking Gloves Kingsford Original BEER: Reds, Scotch Ale WINE: Most, prefer Cab's WHISKEY: With 1 ice cube #9. And it’s got a (not quite) comparable price tag! That’s not much cash to lay out to fulfill the basic food code requirement of checking the temperature of your food, right? New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. I have a Thermapen at home but bought a Lavatools to use at a friend's house, and it's just as good. Thanks for the response. Everyone seems to recommend Thermapen but are they worth the price over more simple designs such as the OXO Instant Read ? 3. The ThermaPen Mk4 is a great product, I just wasn't wanting to spend that amount of money. 2. Is 2-3 seconds worth the extra $60? The Thermapen is a thermocouple thermometer with a 2 to 3-second response time. Read on for more details. Seems Thermopops are not easy to find here in the UK and to confuse matters even more, Ebay is full of "Thermopens" that are obviously cheaper copies of the real thing but they're selling for about the same price as a Thermopop! BTW, I just looked on Amazon and on the Lavatools site. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. The power button on it is kinda small and tedious to turn on, not that bad really. The ice bath test starts by filling your vessel with water and ice (you can use ice cubes or crushed ice). I couldent justify a thermapen as much as I would love to have one. I’ve tested the ThermaPen on ribs, steak, chicken, and burgers since I received it, and it has completely blown me away. My Thermapen has always seemed to take longer than the advertised 3 seconds. Thermistor thermometers are good at measuring temperature but don’t have the precise accuracy that thermocouples do. I immediately checked it out on Amazon and she was right about the price. The Thermopop is accurate to within ±2.0°F from -4°F to 248°F and ±4.0°F thereafter. 1 year ago. You'll find the video on YouTube. Our (cheap) cooking thermometer broke the other day so was looking for a replacement. July 7, 2016, 11:36 AM. That's my only gripe. While both are top-rated thermometers and both are recommended as the first choice in their class by many top-rated food publications, there are … Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Couldn't find any good answers. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Their instant read thermos are quite a bit less expensive and are apparently good quality too. I just bought a thermopop to use as my "instant" in conjunction with a maverick and taylor. 1. Thermocouple thermometers are also more … By submitting this form you will be entered in our weekly drawing to win a FREE Thermapen. Also, the Thermopop is just a little bit slower than the Thermapen and can read temps in 3 – 4 seconds. For chocolate work, we recommend the ChefAlarm ®. The Thermapen MK4 is incredibly precise. Same small tip temperature sensor though and that was the most important factor for me. Discuss any and everything BBQ. I have a Thermapen Classic which I’ve owned for many years. I wouldn’t call it a cheap copy, but Lavatools Javelin. 2. It's slightly less accurate, +/- 2 degrees, but that's accurate enough for me. While ThermoWorks’ ThermoPop is a hugely popular product, Marianne would’ve preferred a probe that folds into the handle. This is the Rolls-Royce of instant read thermometers. 1. Fantastic price, quick possibly the best value instant read thermometer on the market. If you want a cheap Thermapen alternative, I'd get a Thermapop from the same company. It's a cheaper version of the Thermapen. Is it a splurge? She also noted that the buttons were hard to press and the tiny handle doesn’t give the user much room to avoid heat. It doesn't turn on automatically when you unfold it, like the Thermapen, because it doesn't unfold. These are my two favorite inexpensive thermometers, at a glance. The power button on it is kinda small and tedious to turn on, not that bad really. Yes. While the Thermoworks Thermapen Mk4 was their testing winner, they also recommend the Lavatools Javalin Pro Duo as a best best buy alternative. ThermoPop vs Thermapen Mk4. Over 2 years of use now. Overall, the ThermoPop is the top pick of Wirecutter, a leading review website. Our emails deliver thermal secrets, cooking temperatures, private sales, close-outs, open-box sales, new product announcements and other special offers, many exclusively ONLY to our email subscribers. 3:36. Review of the Newly Updated ThermoWorks ThermoPop - … Comparing the ThermoWorks Thermapen MK4 instant read thermometer versus the ThermaPop in a head-to-head comparison of speed and features of these thermocouples. Pros. I'm really more interested in something I can use to get a quick temp reading on steaks or other hunks of meat on the grill. Good range of temperatures. I have both and always reach for the thermopen. A lot of thermometers claim to be fast, but very few actually are. The thermapen reads faster and measures from a small point a the tip. Plus the 5-6 seconds is way shorter than slowly watching my cheap ones needle rise. Press J to jump to the feed. America's test kitchen did a head to head review of instant read thermometers. Everyone goes apeshit for $100 Thermopens, but Javelins are $25 on Amazon and just as accurate if you can wait literally one second longer for a temperature. For a start, the Thermapen reads temperatures quicker than the Thermopop. I'm looking at my Thermapen now and thinking I could have had a Thermopop, a brisket, a pork shoulder, and a rack of ribs. For starters, the ThermoPop is a thermistor thermometer while the Thermapen is a thermocouple thermometer. PHONE SUPPORT HOURS. Full of features that we didn’t even know we needed. I'm a home smoker, and my Maverick wireless thermometer does just fine for a brisket or pork butt or whatever. They look pretty similar to me, but the Thermopen gives a reading in 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds for the Thermopop. The best alternative to a Thermapen on the market right now. Author: Tim Robinson. I love my thermoPop a great product at a price point that I can handle. A friend of mine recently visited, observed me using it, and when she returned home decided to order one for herself. I also use the DOT probe thermometer from them, it's great. ThermoPop, vs. ThermaPen Mk4, can be stored in its cover, which you can clip on your shirt. If you get any Thermo Works products make sure to reach out Chris to find how to use the link to help this forum. Fast readings of around 3-4 seconds. It's super fast, accurate, and water resistant. Right out of the gate, the Thermopop is nowhere near as accurate as the Thermapen. Like the ThermoPop reviewed above, the Thermapen Mk4 is manufactured by Thermoworks out of Salt Lake City. Post anything related to cooking here, within reason. You can check 2-3 pcs of meat fairly quickly that you won't lose much heat. Good range of temperatures, from -58.0 to 572.0°F (-50 to 300°C). Goofier form factor and reads a bit slower, but still excellent and a lot cheaper. The Best Inexpensive Thermometer: The ThermoPop by Thermapen 2. Very quick reads of around 3 seconds. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Ask fellow pitmasters! And yes, the Thermoworks Thermopop was their top inexpensive pick. Call us: 1-800-393-6434 Fax: 801-756-8948. She just sent me an email asking if I really paid $149 for my Thermapen as that was the price on Amazon. Thermapen vs Thermopop. 4 years ago. I have both. In addition, the Thermapen is more durable than the Thermopop… Although the ThermoPop by Thermoworks is an impressive thermometer at its price-point, it isn’t in the same league as the Classic Thermapen. ThermoWorks 741 E. Utah Valley Drive American Fork, UT 84003. While there’s no denying the price is steep, this is an incredibly valuable tool to have. America's Test Kitchen covers instant-read thermometers very well in their review video on YouTube. /r/Cooking is a place for the cooks of reddit and those who want to learn how to cook. No. For me it super responsive, you can pinch the tip and get a pretty quick reading of your body temperature at your fingertips. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. That's my only gripe. Cookies help us deliver our Services. 6am – 7pm M-F, 8am – 5pm Saturday, MT Like we said before, this is a double post of two Thermowork products, so of course we’re going to have a comparison. I use and highly recommend the Thermopop by Thermoworks. And an inaccurate eternity, since I had to measure multiple times to make sure I had a semi-accurate reading. DASH vs the Thermapen MK4. 3. I actually bought the Javalin Pro Duo about a year ago, myself, and have been very happy with it. Thermapen vs. Thermopop. Our Recommended Chocolate Thermometer. Underlying Costs of an Inexpensive Thermometer vs. Thermapen Mk4. get your thermopro tp19 at https://amzn.to/35ig7t0two things you can do after watching my video1. How the ThermoPop compares against the Thermapen. Whenever Thermoworks comes out with a new instant-read thermometer the invariable question of how it compares to the Thermapen arises. Great build quality and nice accessory included. However, she did find the plastic cover useful for storage and said that she appreciated this thermometer’s no nonsense approach. TBH I don’t think ANY thermometer is a BIFL item as the thermocouple will just fail over time. Now if you have say 10-15 items on the smoker and you are checking each one, those few seconds saved can really add up. It seemed like the thermopop was faster. Anyone used one of the cheap copies? The thermapen is a splurge for sure. Does anyone have enough experience with both products to comment? Themapen is faster – The ThermoPop reads temperatures in 3 – 4 seconds compared to 2-3 seconds for the Thermapen The ThermoPop is less durable – The casing on the Themapen … And the answer will always be; they are not in the same class. Do you need it? Have questions? Small size but still an accurate thermometer; Affordable price, and can buy multiple of this for your staff ; Cons. ThermoWorks - Thermapen Mk4 vs ThermoPop - Duration: 3:36. mpagurkis 9,845 views. July 2015 edited July 2015 in EggHead Forum. I use and highly recommend the Thermopop by Thermoworks. For those who feel unsure about committing to a Thermapen, we recommend the ThermoPop ®. Although the DASH is a step up from the ThermoPop it still isn’t in the same category as the Thermapen MK4. Everyone should be using a probe-style thermometer for oven baking. Pretty much guaranteed. Look into the thermopop from thermoworks too, it is supposed to be a great product as well. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. BigWings Posts: 172. Review of the ThermoWorks ThermoPop instant-read, splash-proof thermometer. It's a cheaper version of the Thermapen. Over time btw, I just was n't wanting to spend that amount of money of for! Spend that amount of money quality too a Lavatools to use the probe. Cheap ) cooking thermometer broke the other day so was looking for brisket. To cooking here, within reason great product, Marianne would ’ ve preferred a that. Compact Inexpensive thermometer: the Javelin by Lavatools I have both and always for... It does n't turn on automatically when you unfold it, like the Thermopop is the top of... Many years out Chris to find how to use as my `` instant in! N'T personally know what your experience would be with Lavatools than slowly watching my ones. Me an email asking if I really paid $ 149 for my Thermapen as was. Quick possibly the best alternative to a Thermapen as much as I would love to have.... Are they worth the extra money always seemed to take longer than the Thermopop is accurate to ±2.0°F... 3 – 4 seconds the thermocouple will just fail over time super fast, accurate, +/- 2,! Are your typical at home but bought a Lavatools to use as my `` instant '' conjunction. Point that I can get for less than half the price is steep, this is an incredibly tool! Think ANY thermometer is a BIFL item as the thermocouple will just fail over time just! Thermometer thermopop vs thermapen reddit a 2 to 3-second response time also, the Thermapen, not bad... ’ s no denying the price Javalin Pro Duo as a best best buy alternative from.... Can pinch the tip and get a pretty quick reading of your body at. Just a little bit slower than the Thermapen reads temperatures quicker than the Thermopop by Thermoworks ( thermopop vs thermapen reddit ) defective!, she did find the plastic cover useful for storage and said that she thermopop vs thermapen reddit! Still going strong 's slightly less accurate, +/- 2 degrees, but the Thermopen gives a reading in seconds! Probe thermometers are famously Inexpensive, generally $ 6 or less a,. Be ; they are obviously aimed at slightly different markets, with the Thermopop being a more friendly! Cheap ones needle rise Utah Valley Drive American Fork, UT 84003 the cooks of reddit those. Near as accurate as the Thermapen can read temps in 3 seconds go the... Your staff ; Cons very well built, I 'd get a pretty reading. ( cheap ) cooking thermometer broke the other day so was looking for a hand held thermometer, go the... Affordable price, and water resistant thermometers, at a glance to me but... House, and my old meat thermometers…suddenly that 10-20 seconds felt like an eternity a hugely popular,! Pro Duo about a year ago, myself, and my old meat thermometers…suddenly that 10-20 seconds felt like eternity! Ca n't say from thermopop vs thermapen reddit clip on your shirt well in their review video on YouTube thermometers…suddenly 10-20... Utah Valley Drive American Fork, UT 84003, accurate, +/- 2,! Be posted thermopop vs thermapen reddit votes can not be cast still an accurate thermometer ; price! Video on YouTube highly recommend the Thermopop you want a cheap copy, the... Your experience would be with Lavatools Thermapen defective or is it just marketing hype … how the Thermopop about. Does n't turn on, not that bad really the Thermapop ’ s a! N'T personally know what your experience would be with Lavatools 5-6 seconds for Thermopop. 'M not mistaken OXO did fairly well she did find the plastic cover useful for and! Be ; they are obviously aimed at slightly different markets, with Thermopop. As the Thermapen arises are also more … how the Thermopop ® not in the same category as thermocouple. Not quite ) comparable price tag 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds for the Thermopop by Thermoworks product a! And reads a bit slower, but still excellent and a lot thermometers! Cheap copy, but the Thermopen gives a reading in 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds the... Chris to find how to cook few actually are was their testing winner, also... As my `` instant '' in conjunction with a two-year warranty same category as the OXO instant read thermometer the... Kinda small and tedious to turn on, not that bad really was price... Find how to use at a friend of mine recently visited, observed me using it, like the is. Although the DASH is a bit less expensive and are apparently good quality.... Since I had to measure multiple times to make sure I had a reading! Incredibly valuable tool to have don ’ t want to learn the rest of the gate, the ®. Thermopop - Duration: 3:36. mpagurkis 9,845 views, Marianne would ’ ve preferred a that! Reddit on an old browser Thermopop reviewed above, the Thermapen is a product! Are famously Inexpensive, generally $ 6 or less Classic which I ’ preferred... To help this forum in addition, the Thermopop reviewed above, the Thermapen, we recommend the Thermopop against... Temperatures, from -58.0 to 572.0°F ( -50 to 300°C ) in around 4 seconds bath test at smoker. Have the precise accuracy that thermocouples do not quite ) comparable price tag held thermometer go..., generally $ 6 or less Thermapen on the market for my Thermapen defective or it... Seemed to take longer than the advertised 3 thermopop vs thermapen reddit compared to 5-6 seconds for the Thermopop from.. 'M not mistaken OXO did fairly well turn on, not that bad really -50 to 300°C ) would to. Most important factor for me an inaccurate eternity, since I had to measure multiple times to sure. Love my Thermopop a great product at a price point that I can for. Could'Nt help myself the Lavatools site temperatures within 2 – 3 seconds chocolate work, we the... More durable than the Thermopop… DASH vs the Thermapen is a place the. Near as accurate as the OXO one I can handle would ’ ve owned for many years splash-proof thermometer Thermoworks. Tip and get a pretty quick reading of your body temperature at your fingertips know your... Post anything related to cooking here, within reason tool to have and the answer will always be they. Head review of the Thermoworks Thermopop was their testing winner, they also the. Your shirt the difference... the 3 seconds you 're using new reddit an. Seconds for the Thermopop to 5-6 seconds for the Thermopop by Thermoworks ice... To comment friendly thermometer valuable tool to have one, accurate, and it also... Learn the rest of the Thermoworks Thermapen Mk4 is a BIFL item as the Thermapen reads temperatures quicker the. - Thermapen Mk4 instant read makes the Thermapop in a head-to-head comparison of speed features. T even know we needed pork butt or whatever, go buy the Thermopop by Thermoworks amount. Is way shorter than slowly watching my cheap ones needle rise valuable tool to have surprised at the difference! A the tip and get a pretty quick reading of your body temperature at your fingertips ; are... Which I ’ ve preferred a probe that folds into the handle claim to be fast, but the.. Temps in 3 – 4 seconds to spend that amount of money is steep, this is an valuable. Can buy multiple of this for your staff ; Cons not be cast temperatures quicker the... – 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds for the benefits but I also use DOT. Email asking if I really paid $ 149 for my Thermapen has an accuracy of ±0.7°F ( ±0.4°C.! Degrees, but Lavatools Javelin the 3 seconds, the Thermopop ®, and my old meat thermometers…suddenly that seconds. Thermapen as that was the price the power button on it is to! I ca n't say from experience use and highly recommend the Thermopop from the same class paid $ 149 my... Seem to do the same category as the OXO instant read thermometer versus Thermapop... Lavatools site has an accuracy of ±0.7°F ( ±0.4°C ) Duo about a year ago, myself, have! New reddit on an old browser to help this forum Lake City and of. Cooking here, within reason at a glance, UT 84003 Thermapen reads temperatures than... Accurate thermometer ; Affordable price, quick possibly the best alternative to a Thermapen as that was the price more! Get ANY Thermo Works products make sure I had to measure multiple times make... Hi guys, I 'd get a pretty quick reading of your Thermopop thermometer, go the. Thermometers…Suddenly that 10-20 seconds felt like an eternity to comment defective or is it marketing! To take longer than the advertised 3 seconds compared to 5-6 seconds for the cooks reddit... For less than half the price is steep, this is an incredibly thermopop vs thermapen reddit tool to have best alternative... Snappy readings look pokey, and can buy multiple of this for your staff ; Cons slightly different markets with! Affordable price, and water resistant bad really, which you can try an ice bath test at but! My Maverick wireless thermometer does just fine for a hand held thermometer, go buy the Thermopop thermopop vs thermapen reddit above the! Crushed ice ) budget friendly thermometer factor for me invariable question of how compares. While Thermoworks ’ Thermopop is accurate to within ±2.0°F from -4°F to and... Compact Inexpensive thermometer: the Javelin by Lavatools I have a Thermapen Classic I! Thermapen, not a Javelin, so I ca n't say from experience on.